I've written hundreds of reviews of records for the various radio stations I've been at. I never felt any of them were worth printing. My favorite reviews, actually, were for things that weren't very good, or for things that I didn't have much to say about, so I would take the opportunity to write something dumb. For example, there was a band whose name was the same name as one of my middle school teachers, so the review began like this:
My eighth grade English teacher was named [band name]. I kind of liked her, but everyone else thought she was a servant of the devil because she held us to high school standards. She was small but stern, & obviously loved the stuff she taught us. She introduced me to Poe! Anyway, this band – which is two brothers – has nothing to do with that.
This doesn't help you understand the band at all, so I do describe their sound & what tracks I like. It's standard stuff for a radio review, which (usually) isn't meant to be read by anyone but a deejay thinking about playing a song on the air.
Which is not to say that I don't appreciate criticism. I love to read what people think about stuff. I don't agree with probably most of it, but I don't mind it. Sometimes someone else's opinion reinforces my own - or, better yet, makes me think more deeply about what I believe or think. For some people, however, criticism can seem to be a writer showing off his/her style, or it may just be a bad argument, someone trying to change your opinion, & that can be irksome.
But I was thinking of writing a review of a movie I recently saw, for no other reason than I just saw it. Occasionally I write a review of something on the Internet Movie Database - very occasionally, actually - I recently wrote something for the first time in seven years - but I am rarely moved to comment on a movie in the same way lots of people are & do. (You can read my handful of reviews here, if you'd like. None is essential.)
& then I started thinking, this morning, how much more I enjoyed the Game Of Thrones season four premiere far more than the movie. There were a few dull, expository stretches through the movie - but all the dialogue (& it was a talky premiere) in the television show seemed essential.
& what is the point, anyway? If you like some of the music I like, you'll like some of the shows I've put together. An album review or a movie review or a television review won't make much of a difference. Will it? How could it?
No comments:
Post a Comment